okay he looks great here but i keep picturing the guyliner version of him. so not cute. so i voted dump.

when he looks like this, DO, but when he is gross, nooooo

He's cute but he's such an arrogant *peep* that I'd dump him. Besides... everything I look at him I remember the guyliner face.

WHOA! I hardly recognized him! Lookin' good, Jordan Catalano!

I actually don't like the way he looks here. It's not that he's clean cut. I just think his eyes look sort of weird. Maybe it's because I like "guyliner." But he was hot in My So Called Life and I don't think he wore it then. Or did he?

I would do and marry him. I actually like him better when he looks scruffy, he looks ok her though.

Do, as Jordan Catalano (sooooo dreamy), and in this picture. Otherwise, dump, then shower in super hot water, 'cause homeboy can look tres nasty.

He'll always be Jordan Catalano to me. Wow, over a decade later, I am still bitter about MSCL being cancelled.

I don't even know who this is, LOL.

I love him in this pic on here though, adorable. But I looked up the guyliner version after reading all these comments, and I don't like it at all. I like the scruffy long hair pics of him though, just not the black make-up and all.

P.S. There is no such thing as too dapper. LOL

He looks very feminine here...I like my guys to be more masculine.

I agree Sophia, he may be a charter member of the Gays...

He's a complete nut job. And those are eyes I'd never feel entirely sure of.

Did he get work done?

I miss the guyliner to be honest

I was wondering what was wrong with his eyes...it is the lack of guyliner!!! for some reason without it...it looks like he's had his eyes done.

Do. With the lights off. HAHA!

oh my gosh do.

amazing

I agree, his eyes look different, but perhaps he is just tired. Might be having a too tight schedule. Still looks cute, for I too do not favor the ghoulish guyliner look. It's probably just for show when he's playing rock star, but still looks aweful. I loved his Hephaistion look with the long hair or the longer fringe end of 2004. Gorgeous!

He looks too neat and feminine here.
I LOVE his scruffy, non-guyliner face. He has those cheekbones, and that jawline... smexeh...
Do. Over and over.

i'd do, marry' then dump. no pre - nup though, i need cash. lol. :euil:

He is not a guy to be married to... Do

ok, i'm not gonna lie - i think this guy is really adorable. i will admit i have my moments, like when i'm paging through a mag and he looks like a hobo with the crazy unbrushed long hair and weird outfits - not to mention the guyliner!!! thats a bit much, but hey. . . i'm afraid i don't care how much older he is than me. . . i'd marry him anyday hahaha

i would marry him no matter wat..he look gar8 wat every hair style ..he is jus so perfect..