Are Unplanned Marriage Proposals Better?

by Colleen Barrett 7

None of you had engagement snafus to rival Seth Rogen's jittery, change-of-plans proposal, but OnSugar user NikkiRuby made a valid point. "I would much prefer a Seth Rogan type of proposal over an elaborately planned out one," she said. "The unplanned burst of words just seems more honest."

Proposals can range from highly choreographed musical extravaganzas to impulsive questions asked out of passion, but most fall somewhere in-between. Would you rather yours be more or less planned?