POPSUGAR Love & Sex

How Do Disney Princesses Stand Up to Historical Versions?

Jan 31 2014 - 7:00am

Just like modern-day princess Kate Middleton, Belle, Ariel, Snow White, and other Disney princesses [1] have made their own iconic fashion statements. Illustrator Claire Hummel wondered about the historical accuracy of these cartoon creations, so she decided to do some research and give each princess a makeover based on what she learned.

According to Claire, some princesses were easier than others. Of Snow White, she told Flavorwire [2], it "is pretty easy to pinpoint in 16th-century Germany. Not that the film is accurate, but the clues are there." Others were more challenging. Claire explained: "The Little Mermaid is hard to place from a time period standpoint — Grimsby's wearing a Georgian getup, Ariel's pink dress with the slashed sleeves subscribes to several eras from the Renaissance to the 1840s, Eric is . . . Eric. I went with Ariel's wedding [3] dress as a starting point since those gigantic leg-o-mutton sleeves (so embarrassingly popular in '80s wedding fashion) were a great starting point for an 1890s evening gown."

Click through to see some of our favorites!

Illustrations by Claire Hummel [4]

Disney's Aurora

Historical Aurora

Although Prince Phillip says "this is the 14th century!" during the movie, all the other details reference the 1460s and later (including the 1950s, of course). Claire says she decided to draw a gown from around 1485 for Aurora [5].

Illustration by Claire Hummel [6]

Disney's Ariel

Historical Ariel

Claire used Ariel's 1980s sleeves to inspire an 1890s evening gown [7].

Illustration by Claire Hummel [8]

Disney's Cinderella

Historical Cinderella

Claire's gown for Cinderella is from the mid-1860 [9]s, which would complement the bustle-dress getups worn by the ugly stepsisters.

Illustration by Claire Hummel [10]

Disney's Belle

Historical Belle

Belle's new outfit [11] is inspired by 1770s French court fashion.

Illustration by Claire Hummel [12]

Disney's Show White

Historical Snow White

Claire used material from 1500 to 1530 for Snow White's makeover [13].

Illustration by Claire Hummel [14]

Disney's Jasmine

Historical Jasmine

Claire researched historical Middle Eastern clothing — including her "sirwal" (pants) — for Jasmine's makeover [15].

Illustration by Claire Hummel [16]

Disney's Pocahontas

Historical Pocahontas

Claire recently updated Pocahontas [17] to be "spunky age-appropriate Pocahontas/Matoaka" to be "closer to accounts and illustrations of Powhatan dress" from the 17th century.

Illustration by Claire Hummel [18]

Disney's Tiana

Historical Tiana

For 1920s Tiana [19], Claire "based the dress on Lanvin [20]'s robes de style, which were — unlike the flapper dresses most people associate with the Jazz Age — fitted in the bodice with a wide, panniered skirt."

Illustration by Claire Hummel [21]

Disney's Rapunzel

Historical Rapunzel

When designing Rapunzel [22] from Tangled (which is in a fantasy time period/setting), Claire took some liberties. She notes, "I ended up going with the late Regency. There are a ton of gowns circa 1820 that have those inimitably princessy sleeves, and those palace guards aren't fooling anyone."

Illustration by Claire Hummel [23]

Disney's Mulan

Historical Mulan

Mulan [24]'s setting is complicated due to "the original legend taking place in the Wei Dynasty, the Huns as an actual threat during the Western Han Dynasty, the Forbidden City of the Ming Dynasty, and the hanfu fashion setting it earlier." So instead of putting her in a specific period, she just used "plausible historical textiles and hanfu."

Illustration by Claire Hummel [25]


Source URL
http://www.tressugar.com/love/Historical-Versions-Disney-Princesses-Claire-Hummel-18345067