Do, Dump, or Marry? Gerard Butler

Why, oh, why are some rakish dudes so hot? The rumored Jennifer Aniston paramour (and supposed playboy) is looking mighty hugly in this photo. What do you think about The Ugly Truth star?
Source: Getty
Smart. Sexy. Fun.
nostalgia
2 290 Reasons Why Being a '90s Girl Rocked Our Jellies Off
Editor's Pick
3 Gay Weddings Spread the Love
Video
5 Obama Corrects Elisabeth Hasselbeck and Clarifies His View on Gay Marriage
women
6 Take a Peek at the National Portrait Gallery's Queen Exhibit
Video
7 Are These the Tamest Contestants in Bachelorette History?
Wedding
8 Sugar Bride Guide: Personal Touches
Video
9 E.L. James Knows Her Book Is Impacting Marriages
women
10 Words of Wisdom From Mad Women
Video
11 Joel McHale Talks About One of His Most Revealing Scenes on Community
the royals
12 William and Kate's Year of Sweet Newlywed PDA
nostalgia
13 Celebrity Heartthrobs: Hotter Now or Then?
women
14 The Rise of Weight Watchers in the 1960s
Books
15 Censored: Books Banned For Sexual Content
relationships
16 "Four Years and No I Love You"
community
17 Would Reading This in Public Embarrass You?
the royals
18 See Queen Elizabeth's Diamond Jubilee Celebrations so Far
Music
21 It's Coachella, Round 2! Feel the Love With Cute Music Festival Couples
Mother's Day
22 13 Mom Dates For Mother's Day
the royals
23 Queen Elizabeth Looks Like a Fairy-Tale Monarch at Parliament's Opening
Wedding
24 TrèsSugar's Ultimate Wedding Guide