For a twist on the typical bachelorette toilet-paper-dress games, try this trivia game. Ahead of time, have the bachelorette write up horrible date stories, one per flash card. Then have horrible date stories from The Bachelorette also written up on flash cards, and mix them together. Have the bride-to-be or the host read the cards aloud to the girls (either individually or in teams), and see if they know which is which! A couple of examples:
Q: I awkwardly sat through a dinner with two guys arguing the entire time.
A: Desiree Hartsock (play nice, Ben and Michael)
Q: A guy I was dating told me he lived at home (luckily he was kidding).
A: Emily Maynard (Sean's hometown-date prank)