Thanks to Jonathan Taylor Thomas's 33rd birthday today, we are big-time reminiscing about our favorite '90s heartthrobs. Not only did we see all their movies, sing all their songs, and learn all their dance moves, but we also managed to cover every last inch of our bedroom walls and school notebooks with pictures of the teen stars. We've rounded up the best, most cheesy '90s posters of everyone from Devon Sawa to Joey Lawrence to help you remember your first loves. The poses are even funnier now that some of these heartthrobs, like Leonardo DiCaprio  and Jared Leto , are serious award winners. Check it out!
Now that he's back in style, it's time to take home your very own Jared Leto poster .
James Van Der Beek
How could you resist those sideburns? This James Van Der Beek poster  knows you cannot.
Jonathan Taylor Thomas
We're huge fans of this classic Jonathan Taylor Thomas poster .
The Ladybugs star looks super sweet in this Jonathan Brandis poster .
This Hanson poster  brings us right back to the "MmmBop" days.
This Matthew Lawrence poster  is proof that good looks run in the family.
There's a whole lot of patriotism (and chest) in this old school Aaron Carter poster .
There is nothing more poetic than this Keanu Reeves poster .
You know what really pulls together this Andrew Keegan poster ? His jewelry.
We're not totally sure what's going on with the oversized clothing in this Devon Sawa poster , but we know we love it.
It's like this Josh Harnett poster  is staring into your soul, begging to be put up on your bedroom wall with double-stick tape.
It doesn't even matter if you watched 90210, this Jason Priestley poster  will make you understand.
This Hanson poster  is all about the hair.
Staring at this Backstreet Boys poster , we can almost hear "Quit Playin' Games With My Heart."
He's a long way from Nashville, but Jonathan Jackson still looks adorable on this poster .
Freddie Prinze Jr.
This Freddie Prinze Jr. poster  from the She's All That era is so charming.
The bowl cut steals the show in this Leonardo DiCaprio poster .
Luke Perry's poster  keeps it simple and classy.
Even though there was a clear "No Parking" sign, Christian Slater parks where he wants .
So surprised Justin Timberlake  never brought back his awesome style from this poster .
Jonathan Taylor Thomas
This JTT poster  is just plain adorable.
How adorable is the Boys Meets World star in this Rider Strong poster ?
Erik Von Detten
This Erik Von Detten poster  is everything.
Joey Lawrence's graffiti poster  makes absolutely no sense, and it's perfect.