Dear Sugar,
I've dated my girlfriend for six years. In general, our relationship has been great with the exception of one thing — she hates my parents. They can be control freaks sometimes, but they've never done anything to make her hate them. Her resistance to my family has caused a major rift in our relationship, and she recently told me that she wants to end things. She says she loves me, but doesn't want my parents to "abuse and bully her" for the rest of her life if we get married.

I love my girlfriend, but I love my parents, too. Is it worth trying to reconcile this relationship, or is this just a no-win situation? — In a Bind Barry
To see DearSugar's answer read more.
Dear In a Bind Barry,
I am really sorry to hear about this predicament you're in — I can only imagine how hard that must be for you. You say your parent's have never done anything to make your girlfriend dislike them, but are you sure you know all the information? Even if they have clashing personalities, her strong aversion to them makes me think there is something more to this story.
Six years is a long time to be with someone, so I definitely don't think you should end the relationship without giving it a fighting chance. But if she's just not willing to budge, or at least agree to be cordial to your parents, I don't see how this relationship can work. I wish you luck, Barry.









Flexfit
Valentino
Dorothy Perkins
I think we need more details on this... 6 yrs is def a long time and unless your parents are crazy in medical term, i think your gf should learn to deal with them. Everything can be resolved if you truly love someone...
1Oh and I am so happy to see there are guys out there who are willing to fight for the relationship =)
2tomato is right, we need more info to figure out which of the following possible scenarios is true:
31. your girlfriend is a b*tch/dramatic/overreacting and you need to cut her
2. your parents are ruining her life for real and you need to tell them to mellow
you have to really put some thought into this
obviously the poster is blind to one of the character flaws of one of the parties involved...but we can't tell who without more information
4I'm going through this (um, not like I am dating the question guy, but more like I'm living this senario).
5I've been with my guy for almost 5 years, and in those five years I had worked hard to be nice to his parents but his mother and grandmother are really mean to me (always asking about his ex girlfriend, making it very clear they don't want me around, they even once threw out some stuffed mushrooms I brought over for Thanksgiving because they "looked gross")> For the longest time I don't think my bf realized how much it affected me, it got to the point where I have completely stopped visting his family because I cannot deal with that stress. My bf always said "Don't even pay attention" but if they are going out of their way to make me feel unwelcomed then yay, I pay attention.
I'm probably biased because of this, but I think he should investigate the issue further and pay attention more to both parties when they are together to see who is really being nasty to who.
It does seem like there should be more to this story...even if she doesn't get along with your parents, there are lots of couples with that problem (hence the "evil mother-in-law stereotype). Do you maybe see too much of them? Could you go see them without her sometimes and tell them that you guys are really busy and need them to not just drop by whenever? Maybe if she only had to deal with them once a month she could handle it.
You should also take a hard look at your relationship with your parents...it seems very unlikely to me that she hates them for no reason...do you go running to them with everything? are they too much a part of your lives? do you depend on them too much? do you always take what they say and want over what she says and wants? do you need to work on standing up to your parents and say "this is what we chose"?
You say they are controlling...does that mean they are controlling you? because a relationship is going to have a hard time with an outside force controlling it and you need to take a stand. You sound like a good guy who loves her so it would be a shame if you gave up without trying.
6"They can be control freaks sometimes, but they've never done anything to make her hate them."
Um, doesn't the first half of the sentence contradict the second half?
7Nicely said telewyo
8Why would your girlfriend hate your parents to the point where she is considering ending your relationship after 6 long years for no reason.I have a feeling there's alot more to this story than what you're saying especially if you are describing your parents as being "control freaks" and your girlfriend as saying she doesn't want to be "abused or bullied" for the rest of her life.Something's not right .....
9It sounds to me like he is completely oblivious to how his parents treat his girlfriend. I think the problem is less how his parents treat her and more how he is reacting to it, or his lack of reaction.
10I have to agree with the other comments, something just doesn't add up. I think you should look further into this from both sides. I am also going through a similar situation. I absolutely don't like my fiance's sister, one time early in our relationship she invitied me over to her house, (she just took my number out of my fiance's phone without permission) and immediately led me into the kitchen where on the fridge was a pic of him and his ex-gf from the year before. I know she did this on purpose since she had just moved in a month before. But i'm rambling, I agree that you need to do everything you can to fix this before you give up.
11I've been in a similar situation... relationship:over. It's your family... you need to tell them to make her feel welcome and protect her, especially when they do crazy things! Most guys I know are pretty hands-off when it comes to situations like this, but the reality is that when she is subject to your family, you are her ambassador. You might not see things they do as signs they don't like her, but ugh... it's a dirty, rotten game. From ex-girlfriend references to dirty looks to off-handed remarks about being "unable to trust people these days...", mothers, sisters and even grandmothers can be a girlfriend's worst enemies. Convinced no woman is good enough for their "little man', they'll work tirelessly and sometimes totally under-the-radar to destroy her credibility among other family members (especially of the female variety) and push her buttons to try to bring out the terrible person they think she is. They'll tell you they like her, and act surprised if you say she thinks they don't. They'll talk about her less-desirable traits as if they're a disease and swear up-and-down that it is she who doesn't like them and wants to tear their whole family apart. Doing nothing will get you nowhere, you need to act. Armed with some truth, approach your family and tell them your intentions for this girl. Tell them what you'll do if they continue being cruel (stop coming around so often) and stand behind your words. Most importantly, listen. If it's true that they don't like her, be prepared for an explosion of reasons why you should never marry her.
12Amen, Notinthemood, amen indeed.
13I've been in the same situation. Relationship status: over. We dated for 5 years and all of those years his parents judged me and he rarely saw it. He never knew how difficult it was for me to visit his family. His mother, the main cause, would constantly question my career choice (I work in retail management and I teach), she would always wonder what I did with my money (none of her business, but I saved a lot more than her son), the way she would look at the way I dressed, etc. She was very critical of me, but my ex never saw that, he just assumed I hated his parents for no reason. So, like others, I think you need to find out why she has problems being around your parents.
Also, you need to stand up and be a man. If you love this woman and want to spend the rest of your life with her, you need to make her feel safe and comfortable. When you get married, you also marry the family, so things need to be smoothed over soon.
14I'm willing to bet the parents are toxic and he needs to step back. I'm in the same situation. We've been together 5 years, and his parents are alcoholics who constantly disrespect him and try to control his life. They are extremely passive-aggressive and arrogant, and are always making my boyfriend feel like he's some sort of disappointment to them.
Barry needs to take a step back and figure out why his girlfriend doesn't like his parents. I bet there's more to this than he thinks there is.
15I agree with the others, the OP Barry must be oblivious to what's really going on because it's been 6 years and her reason to want to leave is because of his parents and he has no real idea what's going on?
16OP Barry, if you can't figure it out yourself, how about you ask your gf why does she think they bully and abuse her? And how about your parents? Do they like her? Have they talked to you about her? It's been 6 years, there's bound to be talks, there.
And how about you open your eyes too and really see instead of trying to look at it in a passive rose-colored glass.
I agree with Nutmeg84. OP I can see where you are coming from because you are obviously stuck in the middle. But you also seem really oblivious to the ways that your parents treat your gf. Have you actually sat down with her and listened to how they treat her and how it makes her feel? I mean, REALLY listened, put aside the fact that they are your parents for a minute and just try to understand why she feels 'abused and bullied' by them? I don't think many people would use that term unless your parents have done something fairly bad and severe to her. Also, have you talked to your parents about their side of the situation? Why do they treat her so badly, why they don't like her? How have you portrayed your gf to them? Because in the end, your parents do not make your decisions for you. If you truly love someone, it is up to you to facilitate communication and listen to everyone. Only then can you have an accurate enough picture of what is going on. But either way, your parents do not have the right to 'abuse and bully' someone you are dating just because they don't like her. You need to make your own decisions about your gf's and your future wife, and if your parents are trying to sabotage your happiness then that is not right. If you truly love someone, you should defend her honour and be loyal to her. If you want to break up with someone based solely on the fact that your parents don't like her, then you seriously need to get some backbone. Good luck to you.
17Sounds like we may have a Momma's boy on our hands. If she's willing to walk away from six years, chances are your parents may be sabotaging your relationship. Nip in the bud now. In-Laws, besides money, cause the most riffs in marriage. Do you really want them to ruin your life?
Seriously, I don't care for my in-laws too much. They've let it be known that I was not their choice for a daughter-in-law and quite frankly, it takes too much energy to act as though I'm cozy with them. I love my hubby; but, in-laws can be real pains in the ass.
18been there. ended it. boyfriend didnt see that his dad judged me or would mock me in front of the whole family. would call in the middel of dates and tell him to come home immediately!!! to fix the internet connection. out of those 3 1/2 years i think my boyfriend only defended me once, because other times he didnt see it. i dont think the relationship will work if the parents dont respect you. i would talk to your parents and ask whats going on....because obviously you dont see whats going on.
19oh my gosh lindssaurus...if my boyfriend had a brother I'd swear you were talking about the same father!! I have the same issues with his father and grandmother. His grandma is constantly making snide comments (they're Indian though so she does it in another language that I can't understand without a translation) and his father is VERY controlling..calls when we're out, wants to know when he's going to be home etc....
20It's stressful!!
OP I think you need to step back from the situation and see what it is that's causing this issue. And if it's your parents being overprotective and controlling to an extreme that they're shunning your gf you really need to step in and say something. 6 years is a long time to have invested in someone if she's going to dump you over your parents. That's not fair to you, or her! Especially her. There's definitely more to this if she's willing to walk away because of them, and only you can figure it out and stop it!
I pretty much agree with most of the other posters. If your gf is willing to give up 6 years b/c of your family, there is something wrong that you aren't seeing. Sorry, but guys tend to be so out of touch with other people, so I'm willing to bet your parents are being passive aggressive or downright mean and you just don't pay enough attention to notice.
21If you want to stay with her you need to do the work now. Hear both sides of the story and take what your gf says seriously. B/c obviously she thinks it's pretty serious. And if you decide your parents really are in the wrong, then you need to stand up for your gf and defend her when your parents act rude/mean/w/e. You should respect your gf enough to demand respect for her from others, especially your own parents. If you decide that your gf is in the wrong and your parents aren't really doing anything wrong...then I guess y'all will have to really break up.
I think the OP is clueless. Agree with the above.
I would also add that I wouldn't stick around in a relationship for 6 years with no progression. I would bet anything that the girlfriend is feeling that the relationship is stagnant, and the OP is to blame for that, whether that fact has to do with the parents, I don't know, but the result is the same.
I would also bet that the OP is a mamma's boy and is dragging his feet on progressing in the relationship and the girlfriend has had it.
I don't blame her.
22You need to make a point to stand up to your parents when you notice they start doing something that offends her. You should always be on her side if you see any future in this relationship. When I was in college one of my guy friends even cut himself off finantially to distance himself from the rift his parents were creating in his relationship and in his own life. You're an adult now and make sure your gf knows although your parents are part of the package, they no longer have control over you, her, or your relationship.
23So you've been ignoring your parents antics for 5 years? Let that girl go. She needs someone who isnt as ignorant as you. Imagine what she's been dealing with for you, and you come here and call her a liar. Seriously dude, with boyfriends like you....
24Parents are a larger factor in a relantionship that most people realise, and a lot of the other half need to realise that the g/f doesn't want their decisions/wants influencing their lives
25maybe she has a problem with how close you are with them and shes just jealous or maybe theres something going on that you aren't seeing because youre busy trying to stick up for your parents. why don't you ask her what it is that happened or what they did to make her so upset/uncomfortable. ask for examples and really try not to go defending your parents. if you really feel that you want to work it out with your girlfriend then you need to stand up for her and her feelings while trying to keep the peace with your parents. ask her what needs to be done to work it out. and maybe even talk to your parents once you know why shes so upset.
26and also... if you think this behavior on your parents part will change once you find a new girlfriend... YOURE WRONG. they are prob the kind of people that no one is going to be good enough for you so if u keep giving up people in your life to please your parents that is exactly who you will end up with. your gf put up with it for 6 years so obviously shes been doing her part to try and make it work and if the reason shes cutting off your relationship is because of your parents then something is def. wrong here. this is prob killing her because she cares about you but for her its gotten to be too much. you need to be a man and stop being such a b*tch and turning a blind eye to your parent's bs and fight for your relationship otherwise this will keep happening to you and u will be alone with your parents.
27Oh lord. This is a hit-home issue for me. I'm currently with my guy for 6 years, and all his mother does is bully me, or act like I'm beneath her (for being from the south, or just in general) and that I'm not good enough for her son.
I did nothing to her - she tried to find things to blame on me, such as "I'm anorexic." (when I'm not), or "I smoke" (But I don't. Somehow a lighter ended up in her backseat, but wasn't mine) and this was ALL in the week I met her. I returned home (it was a long distance relationship in the beginning), he told her that he was serious about me. Her response? "She's a little ditzy .. Do you really want to be with that?"
I always get undermined for being from the South. Everything is a spectacle for her. She makes a little thing into a big deal. Constantly questioning my intelligence, and constantly putting me down.
I was nothing but nice to her. Everyone's parents loved me, except for her. The mothers just adored me, but she's just so different.
Well, my boyfriend knows how his mother is, so thankfully, I get stood up for, a lot.
missjules, notinthemood -- in fact, a lot of the ladies in this are 100% correct. You need to ask her what they do that makes her feel this way. I cannot believe how oblivious you've been to her feelings. If she doesn't like them, there is more than likely a reason, and a reason you should've asked about a long time ago.
In the beginning, did they ever spend alone time together? When I did with my boyfriend's mother, all she did was rag on me in a subtle manner, and about my family, and even about her own son! She tried to tell me (or scare me) into thinking he'd never leave her house, and we'd be stuck there forever.
She's done some wicked awful things over the years, in a mental way to get me to leave. My boyfriend does stick up for me, thankfully, and you need to ask her what's going on. And if she leaves, be prepared, because more than likely, it won't stop with her.
28I'm surprised at how many other people have dealt with this situation.. I thought I was alone on this one. My husband's parents hated me (called me a slut, although he was the first person I was ever with).. their hatred was uncalled for. My husband told his parents that after we married they were out of his life unless they changed their attitude towards me. We have been married for almost 3 years and he hasn't spoken to his father since our wedding day. He talks to his mom occasionally, as do I, because she's apologized and tried to make amends.
If your bf wants to be with you then he needs to choose you over his family, bottomline. If he can't do this, you don't want to be with him.
29there has to be more to the story. i hated my ex's grandmother because she tried to come into my house and tell me what to do and take over. my ex was oblivious to this. he absolutly thought there were not any issues.
i think you should let her go she deserves better
30Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.