A controversial new study hints it may be possible to look at a room and figure out how that room's inhabitant is voting. Set to be published in the Journal of Political Psychology the study asserts that empty pizza box is "behavioral residue" that points to "distinct cognitive inclinations" that sends liberals in the direction of ambiguity and intellectualism, and spins conservatives toward order. These inclinations "drive the way one leads one's life and displays one's life in their living and work spaces," says one of the study's authors. Here are the differences they've found — see if you buy their findings:
Conservatives:
- Right-leaners often have spaces filled with calendars, postage stamps, laundry baskets, irons and sewing materials. Fun! Darning socks time!
- Their bedrooms and offices are well-lighted.
- They decorate with sports paraphernalia and flags — especially American ones.
- The study's authors say, "Conservatives have a need for order, for there not to be ambiguity. There you see that expressed by being more orderly, having more cleaning supplies, needing to have everything lined up and organized so that one feels one's environment is predictable and therefore safe."
Curious about that messy room? To find out their findings on liberals, read more.
Liberals:
- Lefties have spaces that are colorful and filled with books about travel, ethnicity, feminism, and music.
- They have music collections covering folk, classic, and modern rock.
- While they're rocking out to the above collection, they're looking at their art supplies, movie tickets, and travel memorabilia.
- The study's authors say, "It's pleasurable for liberals to think more. They gravitate toward art, to things that are not as concrete."
Do some of these conclusions sound. . . stereotypical? Not everyone is on board with the science behind the conclusions. Political scientist Evan Charney, a fellow at the Institute for Genome Sciences & Policy at Duke University, says,
"Confirmation bias has flooded into this [area of] study. I'm a liberal but I don’t believe liberals are superior people or that there's an obvious correlation between personality and political ideology. [The studies] take the most value-laden language and treat it as if you're talking about a left-spinning or right-spinning neutron. They are invariably going to reflect the value assumptions of a society—in this case, academic liberals."
Conservatives, are you home making a McCain/Palin quilt in your brightly lit room? What do you make of this? Good science?









Tory Burch
Nuovegioie
Azzedine Alaia
Very stereotypical, but I guess stereotypes have to come from somewhere!
1Bwaahahahahahaha Did someone pay these people money to do this study? figures.
Its so wrong. conservatives are cleaner, liberals are messy? someone better tell my conservative husband to pick his dirty clothes up and bring his dirty dishes by the computer to the sink! or maybe he is a liberal in disguise? thats grounds for divorce.
2Of course as a liberal I'm all in favor of saying that we're intellectual, artistic and superior people in general
, but OCD plagues as much as the next person. My room is clean.
3Let me just add that by saying conservatives are flag happy, folk music listening, clean freaks and Libs are worldy, creative artsy messy people just furthur builds the walls people are trying to tear down nowadays.
4I wish I were cleaner.
5Go figure. I always thought a messy room was a sign that you were a slob.
6Wow, so scientific. Not buying it. LOL CaterpillarGirl and UnDave!
7I had a bf who used to be super messy (and was a conservative), but then he signed up for the military, came back from Iraq as more of a liberal, and had a spotless apartment ever since. I think he just learned his organization skills from the Marines though, not his political leanings
Also, no one wants to see this liberal do anything with art supplies. Trust me.
8Maybe I am actually a liberal in denial. I am the sloppiest person I know!
9I must say, I'm a liberal and this study hit the nail on the head for me. Messy messy messy!
10If this study is correct, then I must have the most intelligent kids around. Their toys and junk are all over the house.
11Though when I am writing an awesome paper or spending to much time in lab, I do get that mad scientist hair look...
12I am conservative and I am a complete slob. My bedroom looks like someone came and took half my clothes and towels out of every drawer, shelf, and rack and threw them on the floor. I'm also into books and art, and use books and art supplies as decoration.
My finances, however, are kept meticulously in a big green ledger, but I find that where I mess up is buying too much clothing. Could it be that all my stuff is on the floor in piles and I don't know what I have, thus always buying more? The kitchen is always clean and fridge organized, and I'm super good at not wasting food. HMM... is there something to this?
13So that is clearly more ground breaking evidence that is accurate and unstereotyped biased information. In fact I say we go break into Obama's room to make sure he really is a liberal...who's with me!!!
14so not true! I am pretty laid back but when it comes to my apartment everything needs to be cleaned up and in its place..almost obsessively so
and yea..I am a Liberal
15I just read some of these things..so ridic..lol.
now all the liberal stuff kinda does describe me my place is full of art (which proudly includes some of my daddy's art
)and I do love classic rock..BUT this statement about conservatives soooo describes me:
Right-leaners often have spaces filled with calendars, postage stamps, laundry baskets, irons and sewing materials. Fun! Darning socks time
they should add post-its..and highlighters
16My bedroom is always a mess, but I keep the rest of the house very clean. I'm definitely not artsy either and I decorate with tons of sports paraphernalia, but not flags. So I guess I'm a little of both!
17According to this, I'm both liberal and conservative. I'm pretty well organized and clean, and I love a well-lighted space. But I also have tons of music and art-supplies and travel memorabilia. And not a single flag in the house
I'm just wondering how liberals do their art
projects without a well-lighted room? I always found it tricky to paint in the dark. But this part, "It's pleasurable for liberals to think more", made me laugh. I don't think the study had a
slant at all
18My room is full of books like those...
19I am a total liberal, but I am so clean that my family often refers to me as the "Neat Nazi."
20"It's pleasurable for liberals to think more. They gravitate toward art, to things that are not as concrete."
I see myself in the first part. Definitely.
21Here are some common characteristics of a certain nature:
*tend to be intellegent with IQ's in the Bright Normal range
*despite High IQ's they door poorly in school.
*families often have alcoholic histories
*They hate their parents
I fall within 3 of those. I must be a serial killer.
22Oh no! I need to rack my brain to make sure I have never given CG any personal information she could use to find me.
23And I thought the same thing about the slant, Mich.
24Slant you say...who would have ever thought
?!?!?!
25Lilkimbo, I am harmless really, unless you touch any food of mine and i become like Old yeller in the third act.
26That makes me think of Friends. Joey does not share food!
27lol, Me to cg, unless someone uses my pillow. I am a bit OCD about my pillow. And everyone has such a distinctive head smell. I know, I'm crazy.
28Well that is it when I go home tonight the Hubby is being told since he is messy he needs to vote for Obama.
Yeah that'll fly.
29GS--my mom has this thing where she says that some people smell like "dirty pillow". Makes me laugh every time.
30I'm pretty OCD about my pillow too. It's the only pillow I can sleep on. And NO ONE else can use it!
This survey...umm yeah I'd fall somewhere in the middle. My mess has order. It may look messy, but I know where everything is
31dirty pillows....I think of CARRIE.
32When I have canvassed, the only people who were less than polite to me were wearing flags on their person or had flags up in their yard. No conclusions, just saying...
33I have canvassed before and those people were the most polite to me! (Although, I haven't done much this year; this is based mostly on 2004.)
34I think the study is interesting to say the least. It sounded like me the Liberal and my conservative boyfriend (complete with flag) perfectly...and I don't believe either of the descriptions are anything to brag about.
After reading everyone's comments perhaps they need to break it down a little more to add Disciplined Liberal and Undisciplined Conservative.
35I must be both because I am a minimalist - my room is organized and clean, my desk at my office is kept free from disorder. I love making lists to check off - trust me I LOVE order.
36On the other hand I have tons of travel books as well as books on various religions and cultures and many of these books are about women of certain cultures too.
Also my bedroom is well lighted (my whole house is) but my office -not so much. Probably because I am so involved with my work half the time I dont realize someone turned off the lights and I am working in the dark.
Lil K, I assume you were canvassing for the Republican nominee?
37Yes. I kind of meant my statement to back yours up. I mean, of course this study isn't true across the board, but there may be some truth in it!
38I think it would be interesting to look at people in the same age group with different political persuasions and see if this holds true, as well. Of course there are messy 50-years and neat 18 year-olds, but I feel that a lot of times younger people are messier and a lot of times younger people are more liberal. (Obviously this does not apply to everyone.)
39bunch of slobs! come over to the clean side.
i must go dust my laundry baskets...
40Oh, gotcha. There were people who were McCain supporters who were nice, but the flag people were not happy to have an Obama volunteer at their door. One guy told me to move along from his block even though I wasn't even at his door and he wasn't on my list.
It makes me sad that the flag in some way belongs to one party. I used to be a big flag person. Had one on my car, wore a cool vintage t-shirt with a flag (It said "This flag won't burn" or "These colors don't run" I forget which.) When I was young I had a flag in my room so I could say the pledge on the weekends.
But I would never put a flag sticker on my car, now, because I wouldn't want my patriotism misinterpreted. And that makes me really sad.
41I've never been a big flag person. I'm very patriotic and I love our country, but the flag is just not "me," I guess.
42I agree LilK that age probably plays a factor into who is neat and who is messy and in some cases there political leaning. This report is pretty ridiculous. My house is neat, I make lists for just about everything, my expenses are mapped out on a spreadsheet. I also love to read, but hate classic rock.
43"Conservatives, are you home making a McCain/Palin quilt in your brightly lit room?" lmao.
people will do anything to get an article out about liberals or conservatives thinking that they have those two groups figured out.
44it's funny to me.
What am I then? All of those bullets point to me (except the decorates with flags). Ah, and Independent.
45LOL, this is clearly biased and hilarious at that.
46I wish this were true!! Cuz if it were, my house would be spotless and I'd have better lighting! lol...
47Lefties have spaces that are colorful and filled with books about travel, ethnicity, feminism, and music.
They have music collections covering folk, classic, and modern rock.
While they're rocking out to the above collection, they're looking at their art supplies, movie tickets, and travel memorabilia.
The study's authors say, "It's pleasurable for liberals to think more. They gravitate toward art, to things that are not as concrete."
48--------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok you got me. I'm definitely a liberal then. I love collecting movie stus, I'm a music junkie and I was trying to convince my mom to buy pictures of animals in Africa.
*movie stubs*
49Maybe the author of this study was confused? I have travelled a lot, I love other cultures, every kind of music, have tons of books, and always have clothes all over the floor and my house needs to be dusted--really bad! But I would definitely take it as an insult if somebody said I was a liberal. A slob I guess I am, tho!
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.