Yesterday Democratic Rep. John Murtha said that Sen. John McCain is too old to be president. Murtha might have a unique perspective on the age-factor: Murtha himself is 75, four years older than McCain. He says the rigors and stress of running the country is too much for guys their age.
"I've served with seven presidents. When they come in, they all make mistakes. They all get older. This one guy running is about as old as me. Let me tell you something, it's no old man's job."

That "one guy" running, if elected would be the oldest man to become president at age 72. McCain's take-it-easy, senior citizen's schedule in the past few days has included a wild turn with Chris Matthews on Hardball, a big announcement about cutting the gas tax for the summer, and a slot as the cover boy for New York magazine. That's more than I've done in the past 48 hours, for sure.
Ronald Reagan may have famously quipped while campaigning for a second term at 72, that he was not going to exploit his opponent's "youth and inexperience" when the question of his age surfaced — but is Murtha right? Is McCain the answer to the question, "How old is too old?"









Great Plains
Southpole
Burberry
Of course he isn't too old! And, of course John Murtha would say that- he's a democrat!
1My thoughts exactly Tiff!
2Maybe Murtha should stick to his day job, you know, slandering the military...
3And PLATnum Cab
(I found the emoticon bible) says it best.
4Murtha needs to talk to Harry Byrd of WV before he even suggests anything about McCain. And if Murtha feels that way, he should resign and put himself in the "old people's farm."
My parents are 86 and 85 years old and they're still active. This attack on age is an underhanded slam at about a third of the American Public.
Murtha is nothing but an angry old man. Most people take whatever he says with a grain of salt and an aspirin.
RETIRE Murtha!
5McCain is the age of my grandpa! lol
6just as aaliyah sang "Age aint nothing but a number"
7I don't know, maybe age = experience? And if Murtha thinks he is so old, then retire!
8ha ha cine. Murtha might be shooting himself in the foot with this one. Maybe his constituents need to examine his ability to lead at such advanced age.
9Kris, one would hope that would happen, but somehow I doubt it.
10age is relative, my father in law is 71 and you would never know it
11He is not old, he is mature and experienced.
12I totally agree with laurelm - and
I'm back today!
13syako, you can never ever leave again. I missed you too much!
14My Grandfather is 92 and he looks like he is 70. McCain seems to be in pretty good shape, but I am still not going to vote for him!
15dang conferences and 15 hour workdays!
16syako, how do you do the tongue emoticon?
17i'm not voting for McCain but i don't think it's totally fair to attack his age. Yes, i worry that the rigors of the job will take its toll on him, but that happens to every president.
remember how young and healthy Bill looked in '92 and how OLD he looked in 2000? Same thing with W...he looked vibrant and young in 2000 and now...wow, it's not pretty.
The presidency seems to age you at least 3 times faster than normal no matter your party. No matter who's in office, i always feel kinda sad for them because it is a HUGE task to run this country and extraordinarily high stress. i bet if Obama wins, even after 4 years, he'll look like he aged about 15.
18Syako, you were working a conference? i do that too!
15 hour workdays and all day running around a hotel make one just a wee bit tired! hope you recover!
19Ah yes, it's exhausting! Today everything is going to go really slowly. (cine - raspberry)
20oh cine, my book is coming today that you suggested! also i educated someone about Goldwater at happy hour last night. You would have been proud.
21Kris, you just got me all choked up. I need to give you a
You have to let me know what you think of the book! I am so excited now!
22hee hee!
I'm hoping it's on my doorstep this afternoon! Even my friend who was a repub. superdelegate last election had not heard of it. I was like seriously, you of all people have a masters in history and will talk my ear off about politics for hours. am I seriously recommending something to you? what has the world come to?
23yes, he's old! But look at all of the great material Stewart and Colbert are getting out of age jokes. Totally worth it.
24How can he never have heard of it? That is crazy! He will have to read it as well.
25Ha! SoCalSugar! Keepin' it real
26Syako, I did some snooping around sugar last night and found the bible!
Nicachica, I love the Led Zepplin avatar!
27I'm soooooooo proud of you harts!
28The coveted emoticon bible that is.
29Thanks b-t-w for supporting me with those emoticons the other night since EVERYBODY left me to fend off Jillness, Steph, AND Liberty, all by myself. I did ok though. I thought. :pondering:
30awww! What did I do wrong???? wrote pondering.
31awww! What did I do wrong???? wrote pondering.
32
33You guys know I'm just kidding right?
But, I was like this
I kept thinking where's Cabaker and Cine?
I need their witty comebacks!
34McCain is absolutely up to the task...he's got the wisdom that comes with age and experience to deal with the challenges we face. Jack Murtha just doesn't like McCain for personal reasons!
35
harts.
36McCain is unstoppable! That's why he takes Imodium AD.
37I LOVE that most of the comments here are saying that McCain is NOT too old. I am sick of hearing people say that he is!! I understand if you don't want to vote for Senator McCain because of his stance on certain issues, but voting based on age is disgraceful. Age discrimination is a crime in the United States, and people (like Murtha) who say that McCain won't be able to perform because of his age are disregarding this law. Besides, I met John McCain on Tuesday of this week, and he was SUPER NICE and VERY ENERGETIC! He's a cute lil "old" guy!
It's so nice to read comments that make logical sense...that's why I love teamsugar
38Oh, that reminds me of my favorite!! Ha!
how you doin?
39On which post hartsfull???
40Click the link that says "Wild Turn" in the body of this article and you can read about McCain coming to my school, Villanova! I was right behind him on stage...my big break! LOL
41Krys, that is so cool that you got to meet him!
42Oh, that's so great Krys! I knew a fabulous nurse once, who's husband's father, worked with George Bush once. He also said, that GW was a very sweet and really nice man.
Ha! Did that sound too much like, my uncle's sister, twice removed, nephews friends, aunt?
I am goin to town with these smilies!
My daughter is wrestling me for the computer!
43Tiff I've rambled so much, I'm sorry but, which post what? Duh.
44lol! I just wanted to know which post you were fighting on your own in- when you had to fend off Liberty, Jillness, and Steph.
45Tiff, I think I know what you're asking about. Here's where they took off! J.K.
http://www.citizensugar.com/1549360?page=4
46I wrote that before I saw your last post.
47I have to go. I feel my daughters eyes burning in my back!
She REALLY wants to have the computer.
48Bye
who cares if mccain is a nice man, old or young, he's talking about being in iraq/the middle east for another 100 years! he's an idiot. he should be focusing on the only real problem existing in the world today: climate change.
then again maybe he is! maybe his 'strategy' is to keep troops in iraq only until the polar ice caps melt and the zagros mountains have become a seaside resort for paris hilton's great grandchildren.
49I think there are some things that do go with time. We can't ignore that, it wouldn't be realistic. Just as it isn't insulting to suggest that people over 65 should get their driving skills tested regularly. Some responsibilities require physical stamina. Not to say that he couldn't do it, but I don't think it absurd to consider it. Being President is a very big responsibility.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.